A quick internet search revealed that I'm not the only one with troubles, there are plenty of Google image results that look just like the blue my camera thinks this polish is. I'm surprised that most of the people out there say that this color is matte - mine is definitely not. Perhaps the label on my bottle is wrong.
Thats SO Fresh's picture of Savage isn't as dark as mine:
Creative and Polished's picture is probably the closest to how mine appears: